Best Practices for Deployment with the Windows Installer SDKDeploying Windows applications reliably at scale requires careful planning, tooling, and adherence to best practices. The Windows Installer SDK (part of the Windows SDK) provides the components, tools, and APIs needed to author, build, and manage MSI-based installers and related deployment artifacts. This article walks through practical best practices—covering packaging strategies, authoring guidelines, upgrade and patching approaches, testing and validation, and operational considerations—to help you create stable, maintainable deployments.
1. Choose the right packaging strategy
Selecting the appropriate package format and strategy is the first step.
- MSI for enterprise scenarios: Use MSI when you need transactional installs, reliable repair and rollback, and Group Policy / SCCM integration. MSI is the native Windows Installer database format supported by the Windows Installer service.
- MSIX for modern app lifecycle: Consider MSIX when targeting modern Windows versions and when you need containerized, cleaner uninstall and centralized updates. MSIX offers improved security and easier distribution via Microsoft Store or Intune.
- Hybrid approach: Use MSI for core components and MSIX/appx for modern UWP-like components, or wrap specific tools while keeping enterprise workflows in MSI.
Choose based on target OS versions, management infrastructure (SCCM/Intune), and requirement for transactional operations (MSI excels here).
2. Authoring clean, maintainable MSI packages
Well‑authored MSI databases reduce deployment issues and make future maintenance easier.
- Use a structured authoring tool: Use WiX Toolset, Advanced Installer, InstallShield, or Visual Studio Installer Projects. WiX is text-based and scriptable, great for version control and CI/CD.
- Follow the Windows Installer guidelines:
- Respect component rules: one component per resource; stable component GUIDs; avoid sharing file components between features unless truly shared.
- Use features to model product functionality and components to represent atomic installed resources.
- Keep component GUIDs stable across versions unless the component’s key path changes.
- Minimize custom actions: Custom actions are a common source of installation failures. Prefer declarative MSI table entries (InstallExecuteSequence, standard actions) and built‑in Windows Installer mechanisms for file copying, registry, and service control.
- Use standard directories: Avoid hardcoding absolute paths. Rely on Windows Installer folder properties like ProgramFilesFolder, CommonFilesFolder, AppDataFolder, and [ProgramFiles64Folder] where appropriate.
- Properly sequence services and system changes: Use ServiceInstall and ServiceControl tables for service installation and control instead of custom scripts.
- Localize thoughtfully: Keep resources separated and provide MSI transforms (.mst) for localized strings when needed.
3. Versioning, upgrades, and patches
Managing versioning and upgrades correctly prevents installation conflicts and ensures smooth user experiences.
- ProductCode and PackageCode:
- ProductCode: Change when creating a new, distinct product (major upgrade). Keep the same between small updates.
- PackageCode: Must be unique for every build/package — Windows Installer uses it to detect distinct packages.
- ProductVersion: Increment appropriately; Windows Installer supports Major and Minor upgrades. For Windows Installer:
- For a major upgrade (ProductCode changes), author RemoveExistingProducts or use the MajorUpgrade element in WiX.
- For minor updates or small patches, keep ProductCode but update PackageCode and increment ProductVersion (typically change the third field).
- Patching (MSP): Use the Patch sequencing and creation tools to deliver fixes without full reinstall. Patches are complex; prefer minor upgrades if your update footprint is small and predictable.
- Author MajorUpgrade safely:
- Test RemoveExistingProducts sequencing options (before InstallInitialize, after InstallFinalize, etc.) — each has tradeoffs with rollback and file locking.
- Ensure component rules and GUID stability to avoid orphaned files or duplicate resources.
- Support side‑by‑side installs only when intended and design components/features to allow it.
4. Minimize and manage custom actions
Custom actions can break installations across different environments. Minimize use and follow safe practices when necessary.
- Avoid executable custom actions when possible; prefer MSI table-based actions (WriteRegistryValues, CreateFolder).
- When you must use a custom action:
- Use deferred execution for changes that alter the system state and schedule in the InstallExecuteSequence.
- Pass data using the CustomActionData property rather than session properties (which aren’t available during deferred actions).
- Mark the custom action as “No impersonation” (deferred with elevated privileges) when performing privileged operations.
- Ensure custom actions are idempotent and handle reboots gracefully.
- Use signed binaries for custom actions and validate them.
- Prefer service control through ServiceControl/ServiceInstall entries rather than custom scripts.
5. Robust repair and rollback behavior
One of MSI’s advantages is transactional installs—leverage this properly.
- Keep operations inside the InstallExecuteSequence and use standard actions to allow Windows Installer rollback if a failure occurs.
- Use proper sequencing for writing files, creating registry keys, and setting permissions so rollback can cleanly undo partial installs.
- Avoid permanent system changes (like modifying unrelated registry keys or machine policies) without explicit user/admin consent.
- Test interrupted installs and simulated failures to verify rollback behavior.
6. Security, signing, and permissions
Security hardening prevents tampering and reduces deployment issues.
- Sign your MSI and any accompanying EXEs or CABs with a Code Signing certificate (Authenticode). This prevents warnings and ensures integrity.
- Use digitally signed custom action binaries and scripts.
- Least privilege: design your installer to run with minimum necessary privileges. Use elevated operations only when required, and scope them narrowly.
- Avoid embedding credentials in installers. Use configuration at runtime or secure vaults for secrets.
- Set file and registry permissions carefully; prefer the standard account system rather than granting broad rights.
7. Testing and validation
Thorough testing across target environments is crucial.
- Create automated CI builds that produce reproducible MSI packages with unique PackageCodes.
- Test matrix:
- OS versions (Windows ⁄11; server SKUs if targeted)
- 32-bit vs 64-bit scenarios
- Fresh install, upgrade (minor & major), repair, uninstall
- Non-admin and admin user contexts
- Combinations with existing versions of your product or related products
- Use virtualization and snapshotting (Hyper-V, VMware) to run repeated test sequences and quickly revert to clean states.
- Static validation tools: Use Orca, MSIVal2, and WiX validation to detect table errors, orphaned components, and schema violations.
- Use dynamic logging (msiexec /i package.msi /l*vx log.txt) to capture installation diagnostics; analyze and automate log parsing for known failure patterns.
- Leverage Windows App Certification Kit (where relevant) and analyze Event Viewer entries for service and installation events.
8. Telemetry, logging, and diagnostics
Good diagnostics speed up troubleshooting in the field.
- Enable and collect detailed MSI logs for failed installs; include instructions for users/admins on how to generate logs.
- Implement application-level telemetry for successful or failed installs/updates (respect privacy and legal constraints).
- For enterprises, provide centralized logging instructions (SCCM, Intune) and configure detection scripts for compliance.
- Provide clear exit codes and map common MSI return codes to human‑readable messages.
9. Deployment automation and CI/CD
Automate builds, packaging, and testing to reduce human error.
- Use source control for WiX or installer project files. Treat installer definitions as code.
- CI: Build MSI artifacts on every commit or release branch; generate unique PackageCodes and sign artifacts in the pipeline.
- CD: Integrate with deployment tools (SCCM, Intune, Chocolatey, Azure DevOps) for staged rollouts.
- Automate validation steps: schema checks, digital signing, detection tests, and smoke tests on clean VMs.
- Maintain reproducible builds: capture tool versions, compilers, and build environments.
10. Operational and enterprise considerations
Make enterprise administration easier and more predictable.
- Provide silent/unattended installation options via standard MSI properties (e.g., /qn) and transform (.mst) files for configuration.
- Support installation properties and logging for management tools. Document available properties and recommended settings for admins.
- Detection logic: If deploying via SCCM/Intune, provide clear MSI product codes and detection rules (e.g., registry keys, file presence).
- Uninstall cleanliness: Ensure services are stopped, scheduled tasks removed, registry entries cleaned, and shared resources handled correctly.
- Compatibility with management infrastructure: Test with SCCM, Intune, and other deployment platforms for policy, reboot handling, and status reporting.
11. Documentation and user guidance
Clear documentation reduces support load.
- Provide admin documentation with command-line examples for silent installs, sample MSTs, common Property overrides, and detection rules for management platforms.
- Provide user-facing guidance for manual install, repair, and uninstall, including how to obtain logs and contact support.
- Include troubleshooting steps for the most common installation failures and their likely resolutions.
12. Common pitfalls and how to avoid them
- Broken component rules: Keep a stable component GUID strategy and avoid reusing components for different files.
- Overuse of custom actions: Convert to declarative MSI behavior where possible.
- Incorrect upgrade sequencing: Test major/minor upgrade scenarios thoroughly.
- Unsigned installers: Always sign packages and custom action binaries.
- Poor localization strategy: Use transforms or separate localized resources, not hardcoded strings.
- Poor testing coverage: Automate test matrices to catch environment-specific issues early.
Conclusion
Deploying reliably with the Windows Installer SDK means combining careful authoring, disciplined versioning, minimal and well‑designed custom actions, robust testing, and automated build/deploy pipelines. Treat your installer definitions as maintainable code, sign and validate everything, and provide clear guidance for administrators. Following these best practices reduces failures, shortens troubleshooting time, and leads to more predictable, secure deployments.
Leave a Reply